Jennifer White and her husband are trying to keep their sex life as adventurous as possible. Early one morning, Jennifer wakes up to her husband dressed in a sexy Easter bunny costume while he dumps Easter eggs on her. Though Jennifer would love to horse around with her husband, she sends him off to work while she gets in the shower. Her husband pulls her back in for one last round of horsing around, when his son Lucas Frost passes by and gets an idea from his glimpse of their action.

While Jennifer is in the shower soaping up her big tits and firm ass, Lucas puts on the Easter bunny suit. When Lucas comes up behind his stepmom post-shower, she lets him have his way with her because she believes he's her husband. After filling his stepmom with a creampie of hot jizz, Lucas wears his costume into his stepsister's room. Piper Perri is equally open to what she thinks are her stepdad's advances, opening her thighs to take him deep inside her bare fuck hole. When Piper gets on her hands and knees to let Lucas fuck her doggy style, he manages a second climax to give his stepsister a creampie of her own. Piper is totally satisfied until the bunny mask falls off to reveal her stepbrother.

Emboldened by his success earlier, Lucas joins his stepmother in bed starts feasting on her juicy snatch before pounding her from behind. Believing it's her husband, Jennifer lets it happen until she finally looks to see who's fucking her. It feels too good to stop, and they continue on while unbeknownst to either of them Piper is watching and masturbating at the hot sight. When Piper is spotted in the act, she and her mom decide to double team Lucas so he can satisfy each of their twats again. As a reward for his service to their pleasure, the girls stroke Lucas off until he gives them a double facial of cum.